WEEI>On Demand>>MLB Instant Replay not working 4-14-14

MLB Instant Replay not working 4-14-14

Apr 14, 2014|

Mut and Merloni talk about the disaster that has been MLB's new Instant Replay system and discuss all the flaws it has.

Transcript - will not be 100% accurate

Who won non grounded to third grabbed my Roberts fires the second count on their plan is planning posted first finale. So glad she goes now that he's hurt Girardi he's out he may want to question in this and they are looking at it. They're calling him safe at first it. And arrive here. John Farrell. John -- thrown out of the game. And I wasn't very quick injection this is this how has never seen John Farrell. 321 yeah. It was the easiest -- breed of all time. It during math and last night I hope that when they replay that audience being an ass and actually bleep it out for the kids at home because at some point. You're the F Florida the F word and then I believe Brian -- was asked to put the replay system. There with a sun don't shine is that a fair to -- John -- last -- So that a -- Bob Davidson and prostitute him. Not quite sure what it was but the actual the finger went up and -- something about it in the system. It could take the system in in shove it somewhere. EA Iran is -- thing. Based on wondered if you're ever gonna see you manage to -- tossed again privacy that pure emotion that excitement of the game used to bring one point. When the game was the game -- -- price a year ago. Back when men were and now I mad were mad that you like you wanna talk about screwing this thing up let me tell you some people. It's only starting it's only begun. This is go OK. This is gonna get worse wait until this bowl. Transition play panic comes in a Red Sox game and you really sector -- affected by. Day. I'm looking at this game is set right the it and obviously comes off the bag. Does that is that while we -- in his -- For play like that. Is that what we're doing it only brought instant replay and on yesterday to me it was obvious that he -- -- the first of early Wednesday for the third replay that too bad angles of the third angle they gave you on ESPN. The third angle told yeah. They're really say funeral Ronald wants in the outfield he state that runs and score right -- yo what what. I just don't like it I felt like -- -- guys are up they're playing the game of baseball militants try to turn double plays. They are just sort of experimenting. With this instant replay. And guys are out there you know errors guys -- -- -- gave you which. Calls the changed runs scored. It's taken away hits -- given. I don't like it. All right and if you're a guy that loves its three like -- you wanna go all the calls right. They'd give all the calls right. If that's the case that that's why you feel that forget about the challenges from the from the managers forget about it have a little buzzer African hip. -- got a fifth umpire there every time you watch a close play call about called safe do what you bought the guy's gonna talk to look at it that replay but yeah. At any at a kind of get together is an Italian you got that went wrong he say OK both say put him back on. Let's move on with this thing. I tell you what that this instant replay is just it's it's changing it -- you much. It's imperfect game. The trying to make perfectly and it's frustrating I I saw your tweet that OK and a. I think you're wrong about this -- a replay is not the problem. It's the people running replay highlight the idea of -- like -- actually can read and we talked about this at all but -- reading your tweets has -- this is when you broke. -- ever give up the only one the people all the sudden outlaw replay out of the game forget it just too much and all. I wanna get the calls right. I don't like the pick up the calls right the problem I have is that for every play you get what they got that right now runs scored yesterday. Right they they it would Red Sox fan Yankee fan I have Red Sox fan a cost to Ron. But they they missed that plays bars I can tell on the fields are really safe -- the run. It's the day before on Saturday when you say and is up the base who cares I care because when they sit replay has got to put in place. They said you would you -- the correct call they're now messing up replays the way the NFL all the odds. It's not replay a matter it's the way they're instituting it like you're telling me. That -- don't allow the people in Manhattan at this replay senator. Had every angle of the video. -- what the hello we deal would hear if you're gonna -- replay. All rushing. To get it in for 2000 fourteen. If you're going to have all -- stoppages. Get the freak and things right like it's I said it's embarrassing that -- the Red Sox gave Jon Lester. It's embarrassing that MLB has to come out the day after Sunday morning and say. We concede that they call was missed in a game between the Red Sox and the Yankees ESPN New York had a story over the weekend. Watch on the yes network. -- enact game. Like OK laughter and all this will be -- played Deanna came off the base. Try to turn it the -- up -- not slides in pops off at the tags and get some. Carol challenges like -- halt slam dunk that's and how easy. -- they had to say afterwards. That the call shouldn't overturned and it was not overturned in the field quote. The conclusive angle was not immediately available. Wasn't available. You have to work doing the game why couldn't MLB. Look at every angle they have available to -- -- What are we talking about a year this let me replay is a necessity. But when you don't use it correctly. You will bear it's a sport -- that football the next day. It was that -- they were that easy to see that black and white on my TV and TV Yankee fans TV. And -- still -- -- right. And baseball like act sorry -- You know waste our time and still get the wrong that's a -- -- yeah it's clear that the that the replay it was inconclusive. -- and the frustrating part is when when this was rolled out -- explain to us particularly on the throw received by the first baseman. We we were instructed that when the ball enters the -- not that it has to hit the back of the -- Is where the that out is deemed complete. At the same time you know any angle that we looked at you couldn't tell if the foot was on the bag behind Mike nepalese -- so. Where this became conclusive for it is a hard pill to swallow and on the heels of yesterday. It's hard to have any faith in the system to be and so. -- Barrel off awfully critical and as the base of the plan Saturday I'll get him to imply that I think there was more frustration from the night before in the whole system itself because they you know. I this whole thing again I don't know MLB news release a statement what do catches. I never thought that it was when the ball enters a glove that's when you secure the ball in your club when he hits the back your glove and you actually close the glove. That's what -- catches. This transition rule now starting to affect games all over the place -- -- double play -- days old wrist in Tampa Bay. Underhand flip he gets sick clearly with one hand takes a step to go to throw dropped the ball safe. It was a playing Cleveland last week Bob Davidson actually made the call. We Elliott Johnson went up against the wall caught the ball the track. Hit the wall came off the wall to -- a three steps that want to throw the ball into the infield and dropped it. Clear possession. -- So not only do we have students -- replay. But we have changed. What he. Catch is in the game of baseball. Over a hundred years this game's been played and if you catch a ball with your love. And you close it and have control. And take a step all whatever it is that's -- catch. Okay that's a catch I just. I don't understand it did a whole instant replay thing what is the difference. Shortstop throws the ball to first base he catches the ball with one hand. -- -- It goes to throw it around. And drops it. Safe. That's less -- That's gonna happen we talked about this after opening day and and I introduced this this transition roll -- people. And that's not true that's dollar is an all buyers to exit of people call and am telling you they have changed. The role in the game of what a catch is in the game of baseball could be an embarrassment to professional baseball they're like yeah. It's like it's just the replay system I. Meanwhile there's calls out there that are missed -- they're actually reviewing. This calls up there that amidst the -- review is demands are used this challenge. This isn't this isn't baseball we don't I want replay but they have botched electrocution of -- and to that point you you mentioned this before. Not knowing the rules let -- a case of the plate last night cost the Red Sox Iran. Give -- John Ferrell Joey Guinness is John Ferrell after the game explaining what he thinks constitutes. In the possession of the ball at first. When this was rolled out -- explain to us particularly on the throw received by the first baseman. We we were instructed that when the ball enters the -- not that it has to hit the back of the -- Is where the that out is deemed complete. -- to the ball enters the glove the out is deemed complete. That's -- the manager of the Red -- to what he said he was told about the system lets your John crock last night. Explaining what he was told in ESPN broadcast Booth about receiving a ball for space. Remember we were up in New York for these meetings that they say that the ball had. You can't -- just in the glove it has to be secured in the glove. And look like what's your -- could hit that Napoli hit yet the closest -- it. -- -- and Farrell -- told the exact opposite thing for Major League Baseball. Which one's true. When you're playing -- which was truthfully Ferrell certainly crux that truck. So how does the manager -- Wrong I don't know ought to -- does goes to -- because I don't know how anyone could rule. It a catch when the ball enters the -- area of enters the glove. Get a secure the catch ya it's got to hit the back you're glove and you and you gotta squeeze it. Okay that's what he catches. And once you squeeze it in Chile who have controlled the ball in your glove it's an out. This gig got it you can't catch a baseball -- three putting your bare hand to throw. It's somebody explain that to me. It's not a catch until you put the ball in your bare hand and throw it in a direction. That is an afterthought that is what happens after the catch. And now they're telling me that that that's part of it actually being a catch. It makes no sense. The raid that kind of stuff you know the transition -- didn't really happen to it as a parent can happen with the Red Sox. You know quite yet I guess you could say -- I think that was more of the ever have control of it. But it is it's gonna happen. In a ball in the dirt the other day when Brian Roberts obviously filed -- guys said it caught a year obviously didn't get review that don't know why at that we're trying to go calls right. -- Texas as you want it to replace you gotta stop you bitch and I never want instant replay I did I was can relate to open up a can of worms and it has. Now all Ellsbury can lose weight try to play baseball season -- -- -- game. That of the -- this game for a long time managers that in his game for forty years. Don't know. What do catches anymore. You know when -- talking about something substantial has reported being brought in the game there's going to be some a learning curve and everyone becoming familiar puts. Again and there's you would think that video replay would be conclusive or there's play is where it's not conclusive which is tonight and a fortune on the wrong -- of football cards. Frustrating for me the yet to different TV stay told me and never got the one on Saturday didn't affect the outcome of the game with the bigger picture folks -- baseball. Are they using the angles they have what the hell they doing and a Manhattan office secondarily. Listen IE here -- and Ferrell again it's a small point but we did both guys at their word. Tell me baseball could explain -- credible the manager and it a guy or three SP and a former player. That's frustrating to me. That's an embarrassment the baseball -- likes to say. Advocated get the communication to the managers and or media correct could be an embarrassment to professional baseball it like we're guy who played. The game is now on ESP again. Called the games says one thing. The guy managing -- -- -- group also play the game says another (%expletive) they were explained it the opposite thing by Major League Baseball. That's in about -- meant. It's -- it's I bought for his replay I like replay. But the execution of it and the the things that are not every play. It's not -- -- baseball fan. They got to tighten this thing up pictures of the got a call I'm not regroup -- at -- clearly what. Second time about it in net and get regroup and is at the game more and that -- position thing earlier in the game. Alex Gordon caught a ball got to left field line caught it. Obviously everyone who's ever seat watching a baseball game caught it hit the wall. Belted a ground rolled around for a few seconds. Actually stood up. And they want to throw the ball in and dropped it. -- -- and Joseph Maddon you know later on the game they -- about the sober play went out and civil. I've challenged. Alex Gordon does I've played in the -- a long time that that was attached to Bibi tell me that wasn't a catch. And the guy actually said not -- that one probably was. Because you Willey wrote on the ground for like kind of headed for a long time. Up before he tried to throw it out. That's incredible skinned and so is terrorist. What I catch a third outlined drive and pass -- just run and all the way with that brought to be careful when a flip it to the stance that I don't drop the ball wanna put the to a fans like there's a time limit. What what can we just released a statement. And look for that a change G a rule that's been going on now for 130 years. -- -- announced the new rulers so everybody is understanding the fans included. What the -- a catch 61777979. 37 a phone number AT&T text line is 379837. -- not cost the Red Sox the weekend. They're -- plays and decisions emitted from Boris or position that cost the Red Sox the game. But the bigger picture is number two weeks sample size a replay will never really wanted to I did. Angle of us agree it's not being good and baseball has a lot of explanations to make about the system. Is their barracks in their game right now the weather X acute it pulls in a car waiting patiently atop replay Paul what do you have. These guys aren't really a lot of plays in the history of baseball the last thirty years. If I'm wrong that -- change of course like to pick him maybe about work separate. Sort of bit players -- umpires the movie. Yet. Rush late last year from the World Series they -- to repair person call. This morning that it's a place and I needed for the big long calls. And the challenges you're right it's like to show. A lot of -- -- important to -- to support this limelight. Being. Away. Just competitor go out there like what -- I'd like cute that you look at this it's available. And attitude right last year. There -- great guys aren't out to -- You don't you about managers now I think going out thanks ball. And go against their better judgment. And challenging certain plays because they now know that. Things are different. You know they'll go in. Knowing that the guy caught the ball but -- -- disable you know what I know he got the ball. I'm no baseball for a long time but with the new ruling I don't think that's a catch on -- to go and try to you know take advantage of this. I think we've gotten scared away at its its like to we have always threatens. The -- is that replay in the NBA if you expanded at every demagogue to the ball in the hole. And a call to follow these guys that idiom and coach -- I want to replay that because I think my guy got all ball. Well let's go check it out. I mean it I must feel like baseball is like that MBA like you know you -- -- follow on got all ball our own that's what challenger. Let's go look at it. It is to get that mistakes. Like the home run calls I get fair foul balls okay. But whether dean and -- put came off the bag slightly after a slide that's why instant replays here it's not. But yet. Open the door so now I can challenge it. You better get a right. And they still -- That's -- frustration for me I like that play like dean in a plays -- -- the guys out I want to be called out but you have to get it right that's you -- if you're gonna do it. Do you take -- manager's hand the umpires hands. Let's let's eighty matches before and this is the way -- should have been -- -- we agreed on this -- from New York coach -- it go look at it. And -- look at the right angles. Like you tell me you -- ready -- baseball but you guys on the angles look at even though yes network has the -- they showed over and over again on on ESPN that day. That's a rush job by baseball and it's costing you -- credibility when it comes three play. With your fan base bodily 61777979837. Out of the phone a breaking anti tax law. 379837. You guys stacked up Aguirre -- your phones you're a Sports Radio WEEI.

Audio On Demand

Tom E. Curran, CSNNE, Rec…

Tom E. Curran, CSNNE, Recapping Patriots OTAs 6-20-14

Tom "Eugene" Curran joins the guys to discuss how the Patriots look coming out of OTAs. Then Christian and Lou discuss the Patriots playbook scandal.

It Is What It Is Cast: Tom Brady's present and future

WEEI.com's Mike Petraglia and Chris Price discuss Tom Brady's work in mini-camp and his response to recent criticism of his play.

Tiki Barber discusses Stevan Ridley's fumbling problem. 6-12-14

Former NY Giants running back, Tiki Barber talks about Stevan Ridley's fumbling problem and reflects on what he did to fix the problem while he was still playing

Jackie MacMullan, ESPN Bo…

Jackie MacMullan, ESPN Boston, "I think Rondo is going to go, I just don't see where and how yet" 7-17-14

Jackie Mac joins the guys to discuss her thoughts on a possible mid-season tournament in the NBA, LeBron's return to Cleveland, trade rumors with the Celtics and Red Sox, and Darrelle Revis' contract situation.

Jackie MacMullan, ESPN Boston: I believe Rondo will be traded 7-10-14

Jackie MacMullan of ESPN Boston to talk about the Lebron James Saga, the possibility of Rajon Rondo being traded, and the future of Marcus Smart.

OK State Men's Basketball coach, Travis Ford, joins MFB to talk about Marcus Smart, 6-30-14

Former coach of Celtics 1st-round pick Marcus Smart, Travis Ford joins MFB to talk about what Celtics fans should expect from the strong point guard. Among other things, Coach Ford says Smart will be a hard worker, and will improve his shooting ability.

The Bradfo Show: Talking …

The Bradfo Show: Talking hitting leadoff with Brock Holt

Rob Bradford is joined by Red Sox leadoff hitter Brock Holt, who since being inserted into the top spot in the batting order has been among the best leadoff men in baseball. Heading into Tuesday night, no other leadoff hitter has had more hits (77) since May 23, with Holt having played every inning of every game during that stretch.

Stephen Drew after the Red Sox beat the Blue Jays 14-1

Stephen Drew joins Joe Castiglione and Rob Bradford after the Red Sox offense continues to roll in a 14-1 victory over the Toronto Blue Jays.

Jon Lester with Joe Castiglione after completing the sweep of the Royals

Joe C. talked to the Sox ace after he

The Bradfo Show: Talking …

The Bradfo Show: Talking Bruins roster moves with DJ Bean, Turtleboy

Rob Bradford is joined by WEEI.com Bruins beat writer DJ Bean, as well as Boston sports fan/blogger Turtleboy to talk all things Bruins free agency. With the B's recent moves, the conversation turns to where the Bruins might next turn and what kind of dent losing Jarome Iginla and Shawn Thornton might make.

DJ Bean breaks down the first hours of NHL Free Agency 7-1-14

DJ discusses Shawn Thornton's new deal, and the on going negotiations with Jerome Iginla

DJ Bean, WEEI.com. The Bruins are not traded Marchand 6-13-14

DJ Bean joins the program to dismiss the recent rumors that the Bruins are in discussions to trade Brad Marchand to the Sharks for Patrick Marleau

Steve Buckley on Tony Dun…

Steve Buckley on Tony Dungy's comments 7-22-14

Steve Buckley joined the show to discuss Tony Dungy's comments on Michael Sam.

Headlines, Headlines, Headlines: Energizer Bunny and Bill Clinton 7-22-14

The top stories of the day as recounted by John Dennis.

Tony Dungy would not draft a gay player 7-22-14

The guys discussed Dungy's comments on Michael Sam.

Upon Further Review: What…

Upon Further Review: What is clanging around in my ratty old backpack? 7-22-14

Christian started the day by packing up his back pack as he always and heading to work. He noticed that the zipper was broken on one of the pockets. As the show was ending, he remembered this and reached into the bag and pulled out not ONE, but TWO New England Patriots Super Bowl rings. His response: "Oh! There they are." Much to the shock of Tim and Lou, Christian was completely unfazed by the fact that he hadn't seen his SB rings since the NCAA National Championship game 7 MONTHS AGO!

Three For All: Is 9 years old to young to be left alone? 7-22-14

A South Carolina mother was arrested for allegedly leaving her 9 year old daughter alone for hours at a local park while she worked a shift at McDonalds. This has sparked a national debate about whether or not the mother should have been arrested, since many are arguing that 9 years old is old enough to show dependency. The question arises: Where do we draw the line?

Cyd Zeigler of OutSports.com joins MFB, 7-22-14

Tony Dungy is catching a lot of backlash regarding his comments that he would NOT have drafted Missouri LB Michael Sam because of the distractions it would have brought to the team. MFB had Cyd Zeigler of OutSports.com on the show to discuss Dungy's comments.

Where is David Ortiz's ri…

Where is David Ortiz's rightful place among the all-time great Red Sox players?

We discuss the home run achievements David Ortiz made last night that moved him ahead of Carl Yaztremski, and discuss Papi's place among all the all-time great Sox sluggers.

Dale and Holley's Four at Four - Unexpected Phenom Edition - 7-22-14

We tackle four topics all sparked by the unexpected emergence of young Brock Holt in the Red Sox lineup.

Tony Dungy wouldn't have drafted Michael Sam, 7-22-14

The fall out from Tony Dungy's comments about Michael Sam.

Jon Lester's Contract Sit…

Jon Lester's Contract Situation and the Future

Mut and Villani are talking about whether the Red Sox will give Jon Lester the type of contract he is looking for, or whether they might be shopping him with rumors of the Red Sox scouting Cole Hamels.

The All Star Game and the Worst Ideas in Sports

Mut and Villani are talking about the MLB All Star Game, Adam Wainwright and Derek Jeter, and what are some of the worst ideas in sports.

We're all yelling about LeBron James

The Bradfo Show: Talking …

The Bradfo Show: Talking hitting leadoff with Brock Holt

Rob Bradford is joined by Red Sox leadoff hitter Brock Holt, who since being inserted into the top spot in the batting order has been among the best leadoff men in baseball. Heading into Tuesday night, no other leadoff hitter has had more hits (77) since May 23, with Holt having played every inning of every game during that stretch.

Producer's Podcast with Julian Edlow 7-22-14

This week, Sam Packard and Zach Geld talk about the Post-Pierzynski Red Sox. Julian Edlow of the Green Street Blog, joins the program to analyze the Celtics off-season, and finally an over-eager discussion of fantasy football.

SoccerCast - Liverpool Midfielder Joe Allen

In this episode we talk about transfers across Europe, players we want to see in the MLS, and Liverpool's Joe Allen joins the show!

Peter Gammons on the Sox …

Peter Gammons on the Sox and Jon Lester 7-21-14

MLB HOF'er Peter Gammons joined the show to discuss what the Sox will do with Jon Lester.

More from this show

Steve Buckley on Tony Dun…

Steve Buckley on Tony Dungy's comments 7-22-14

Steve Buckley joined the show to discuss Tony Dungy's comments on Michael Sam.

More from this show

Sox seem to be alive agai…

Sox seem to be alive again, so are you back in?

We talk Sox after a sweep over the Royals at Fenway. We look at fan interest and how nothing in the AL East is even remotely decided at this point.

More from this show

Jon Lester continues to d…

Jon Lester continues to dominate 7-21-14

John, Gerry and Jerry Thornton discussed the Red Sox sweep of the Royals.

More from this show

Has the city of Boston go…

Has the city of Boston gone soft on the Red Sox? 7-21-14

The guys respond to a Dan Shaughnessy column that points out that the Red Sox are on pace to finish in last place for the 2nd time in 3 years, yet ticket prices still remain among the highest in the league. Is Red Sox nation getting fat and happy now that the Curse of The Bambino has been lifted?

More from this show

Weei Writers