WEEI>On Demand>>Public defense attorney Professor Birckhead on the Dzhokhar Tsarnaev trial

Public defense attorney Professor Birckhead on the Dzhokhar Tsarnaev trial

Apr 23, 2013|

Professor Birckhead joined the show to discuss the ensuing trial of suspect #2 in the Boston bombing case. She used her background of being the public defender of terrorist Richard Reed to serve as a guide for what will likely happen in this trial. The professor told the program that in order to maintain the great justice system we enjoy we must vigorously defend all Americans.

Transcript - will not be 100% accurate

Welcome back it's Dennis and Callahan 61777979. Resettle about your phone calls in just a bit we pause for some much legal advice from legal expertise. From someone who knows that a little bit but a lot about what is about to transpire and has already commenced here in Boston. -- Tamar -- University of North Carolina law professor criminal defense attorney. Juvenile justice advocate. And she defended Richard Reid the shoe bomber joins us on the AT&T hotline good morning mark -- John and Jerry here in Boston thanks for taking a few minutes. Sure are more as far as you can tell how daunting a task does Miriam Conrad have. As the public defender for suspect number two when this trial commences in the US justice system. It's pretty daunting. On top of the nuts and bolts. It's sending him. And. Revealing. That tried it says as that the federal government is. Is a -- saying you've got the media. To. Negotiate and the federal defender office in Boston as a small. Out there that they're you know it's federal sequestration. Budget cuts. And they don't exactly have -- communications liaison. Or that attained so you know you when I was in that position and I I. And the experience of writing my own pat truly is -- So that they. There's a lot. And it can be a lot of scrutiny. I'm sure that every decision that's made. But here it is. Excellent lawyer. Talks to Haitian. Can I confidential cute. The baskets and possible. Right setting aside the issues of obstacles and and scrutiny and short staffed and all those sorts of things in the face of what appears to be absolutely insurmountable. Evidence -- If you were Marion Conrad. What would your approach be. How would you attack that attack this problem. It well. Inherited the charges in the complaint carries the death penalty potentially there'll. A big part of this strategy. Right now it's going to be mitigation. Making sure that. Information gets out there that it's -- in nineteen year old. That he had someone stand. That he had been in trouble before daddy would probably acting under the influence. Very strong personalities. Older brother. And you know and nineteen I mean he didn't have the right to drink alcohol Massachusetts. And brain we're barely you know fully develop. I still. That's the kind of think they're going to be exploring and are going to be looking into his background and and thinking it had its two mitigation in addition to. You know arguing that the tentative evidence it's the other that seem overwhelming to us. You know we don't yet know we know at the chart part of the complaint but once there's an indictment. There could be additional charges we don't know what they are we don't know why they're gonna require. The US attorney's office to prove. And all of that it's gonna have to be -- it will be reviewed by -- that are colleagues. You know very closely rigorously. Now I know as a lawyer you have to zealously defend decline throw everything against the wall the you have your disposal but when you say. You know he was young is his brain was barely developed or that he didn't have a criminal record. You really believe that matters I mean he's he he's he's accused of blowing up an eight year old boy of excusing and any cop in cold blood. You think it matters that he doesn't have a criminal record. I think it matters in terms that is the ultimate penalty its gas. You know our our US Supreme Court. In 2005. Hell that it's unconstitutional. To execute. Juvenile offenders you know meaning and younger than eighteen -- he's old and eighteen but a lot of the same arguments apply. So you know like I -- for bought and bought it for fifteen years. I feel deeply for the people that he had a -- friend former colleagues there. I had my prayers are with them. It is this is not to say. That he shouldn't or won't be punished. We're. Execution on the cable. It's a whole other. You know ballpark for where the defense counsel. And at that point it's perfectly appropriate. Also say you know in terms of sentences to life without parole. You know. US Supreme Court has also recently. You know mandatory life without parole sentences for juveniles. Are. Unconstitutional. You guys not juvenile if this. If -- established if established ages eighteen all right it's a team what's the difference between nineteen and 46 or nineteen in 226. At the numbers eighteen why does that matter he's nineteen. Or 29. Well it'll it'll matter to the judge can sentence and there. You know we we believe an individual individualized sentencing in this country. The criminal case itself. -- maturity all of that will be taken into account we're talking about it and he lied about pearl. We're talking about and it could be seventy years. That that secretly get treatment. Aaron you know maybe -- at what our identity to be perfectly legitimate -- -- at that point. The judge will be thinking about his age. We're talking with the University of North Carolina law professor defense criminal defense attorney Tamar Birkhead who defended Richard Reid the shoe bomber. -- essentially what you're if not acknowledging your at least acquiescing to the fact he's probably be going to. Found guilty -- trying to keep him alive that said. What if he wants to be martyred. Mark what if he wants the death penalties that we can join our lot and his brother how -- that monkey wrench affect the paradigm you're going on as defense attorney. Well it's the criminal defendant Schilling. As to whether or not to go to trial court to plead guilty. And that's difficult situation of course they can advice yeah. There has -- dependent. Who has its its its target test penalty. Rather than life without parole there. You know that it -- argument that life without parole is it is actually more -- -- More. A much more harsh a penalty that yet. And in -- they'll just have to he Marion and her colleagues we'll have to see what his attitude. If it's in terms. The options but from what I've read. Even though he has been cooperating. He's spoken. Federal agent. He cooperated at his arraignment he said he wanted to have counsel. He's an American citizen Utica college student. Into the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. It it to. I'd be very surprised. Arbitrary if he takes that patent. It Richard Reid want you to save him. Do you want me to sit him out he he wanted to go to court and just say what he had done. -- with four. Except you know take responsibility for what -- it. He didn't didn't wanna be a martyr like Khalid Sheikh Mohamed is not assisting as the fans correctly once the guy you -- you know he wants to be -- Our is that common I'm assuming and is a monkey artists. I didn't say you know each each. Personally it's different. Latin and people might say one -- before they've they've committed -- sacks. And after the fact when they're actually looking at. The consequences. There that you might change firm. So it's. It's really hard to you know I would want to generalize. The -- in your estimation does it take -- a certain person of resolve or certain model resolve. To defend the most hated people in entire country I mean it seems to be by and large not a 100% of the time but prosecutors are admired and beloved. And defense attorneys are looked at with scorn and ridicule as it takes a lot of resolve to defend that the most hated. -- imagine. At that differently I mean I consider. It's considered it a privilege. Q -- in that role I think that -- criminal justice system is critical if we don't have. Excellent -- is different. Who are the most hated. There's very little that separates our system from. In. The worst. System in the world. Still. You know I say bring in. It's it's. A little lies injured on Q and I imagine other execute -- where are drawn to. And it's an important one and it you know I I have -- the American people that. It despite. There anger and harder. Yeah. There -- here. Which emotionally I certainly share capital -- In Boston that's where my children were born. I can't say that people understand. -- you know it is constitutional rights due process rights. Are extremely important. And if we don't uphold them in this scenario. You know what's gonna stop us from our kicking short. In any other case. Are a joke cars public defender Miriam Conrad recently wrote and I'm interested to see tomorrow if you would agree with the sentiment on a general basis. From a personal standpoint I would say there are very few clients I have had. I didn't light. It just scratched the surface many -- had difficult lives and as their attorney I sort of see them whole not just as a person charged with a crime. No one has ever stood up for them and that is a very powerful emotional thing. Can you relate or not to that. I like I relate completely to that time I'd like. Just about every client I've had during my -- That's practiced over the -- you're the last twenty years. I would I would think they had. Most people would agree we are each more and the worst thing we have gone. And you know -- 99.9. Percent of the time. People are punished quite severely parsley in the country for criminal acts. But that doesn't mean that that is all they are add. My clients. Has including Richard Reid has shown. Great respect -- me. You know we had established the poor under very trying circumstances. He didn't kill anyone correct professor. Now if they if you had to defend Osama bin Laden do you think you'll like them. There -- like can I I don't know but I wouldn't try harder. Deputy ethical -- our defense counsel. Is. Common ground and to establish report says that you have that trust that your client and you can represent them. Rigorously. In -- you know part of what we must do. You don't have to like I mean if you defendant Mohamed that that you think you would like that after he killed 3000 people at the admin who you know. If he wasn't on you could like a guy know when he killed 3000 people. I am I I am I'm. Not my prediction to judge. It gets it I can't. Relax these ads basically -- -- -- overall and I and that professional role. I talked to my client they're human beings and I try to connect. Yeah. You know does that mean I end up liking them are often. You know I do -- -- the job and you judge them if you like them you judge them. -- You know why I -- I I think that distinction between between those two. Emotions. I mean I can I'm developing or for relief that can be light can't. -- I can sit down with the car that we can discuss the legal issues. We can treat each other with respect. I can feel. Sympathy for something that they may have. What do -- what do they blow up your kids at the marathon finish line would you be able to the would you judge. I think that's an impossible scenario. As possible. I mean I can say that I was in Boston working in the federal courthouse downtown on nine elevenths. -- three months later I was representing Richard -- And eat you know you've got a professional role you've got a personal role. And in order to do that kind of work for decades you need to be able to separate output to. And -- like let's say you're thank goodness. That -- people. Out error. To -- or our system would be a whole lot of trouble. We're talking -- defense attorney Tamar Birkhead filed a question for me as we sort of bring this full circle what would you be looking to accomplish during jury selection Tamar. If you're the attorney for a a joke -- Surely that's going to be extremely. Challenging because you've got the idea of finding. Jagr who has not -- either directly impacted I -- -- think the public. -- -- the Greater Boston area who are impacted by the locked down. You know 100000. People. 83 you've got all those people who are directly impacted and I would think you know I merely. Everyone in the commonwealth may have been indirectly tactic either by the attacks. Or by a locked yeah distress. That experience and you need folks on the jury. Who had not been either directly or indirectly impacted -- can be objective fact finders. So I would say that it could be a good chances. Requests trick change in venue. In that instance so that you could. Potentially. Flying to church who could -- into the -- as. And check it. You know without emotion. And mr. -- -- University of North Carolina law professor criminal defense attorney she. The defended Richard Reid the shoe bomber thanks for the information as -- pleasure talking to you this morning that Berkett. Sure. She joins us on the AT&T hotline AT&T by the way it's set up a text to -- line to benefit the victims of the Boston Marathon bombing. Text the -- Boston. 80108. To donate ten dollars to the one fund Boston message in battery supply. -- full terms at M give dot org slash T. -- Boston or Boston to 80108. And donate ten dollars -- the one. -- -- Where your phone calls that doesn't count it.

Audio On Demand

It Is What It Is Cast: Ha…

It Is What It Is Cast: Has Darrelle Revis' impact actually been underplayed?

WEEI.com's Mike Petraglia and Chris Price discuss the latest development at Patriots training camp. Chris says Darrelle Revis has looked great, and that his impact on the defense is actually being underplayed nationally.

It Is What It Is Cast: Gronk will continue to smash and dash

WEEI.com's Mike Petraglia and Chris Price discuss Rob Gronkowski's meeting with the media on Friday. Gronk said he doesn't anticipate changing the way he plays, noting that he wants to "keep smashing and dashing."

Julian Edelman After Patriots Practice, 7-25-14

Julian Edelman joins Merloni, Fauria, and Benz after Patriots training camp.

Jackie MacMullan, ESPN Bo…

Jackie MacMullan, ESPN Boston, "I think Rondo is going to go, I just don't see where and how yet" 7-17-14

Jackie Mac joins the guys to discuss her thoughts on a possible mid-season tournament in the NBA, LeBron's return to Cleveland, trade rumors with the Celtics and Red Sox, and Darrelle Revis' contract situation.

Jackie MacMullan, ESPN Boston: I believe Rondo will be traded 7-10-14

Jackie MacMullan of ESPN Boston to talk about the Lebron James Saga, the possibility of Rajon Rondo being traded, and the future of Marcus Smart.

OK State Men's Basketball coach, Travis Ford, joins MFB to talk about Marcus Smart, 6-30-14

Former coach of Celtics 1st-round pick Marcus Smart, Travis Ford joins MFB to talk about what Celtics fans should expect from the strong point guard. Among other things, Coach Ford says Smart will be a hard worker, and will improve his shooting ability.

Tim Kurkjian, ESPN: Red S…

Tim Kurkjian, ESPN: Red Sox are in a tough place with Lester 7-28-14

Tim Kurkjian joins the program to discuss the Red Sox options at the trade deadline.

Christian Vazquez with Joe & Daveafter the win at Tampa Bay

Kevin Millar, MLB Network: David Ortiz not afraid of David Price, 7-25-14

Kevin Millar joins Merloni, Fauria, and Benz to discuss David Ortiz, Dustin Pedroia's struggles, and Jon Lester's contract.

The Bradfo Show: Talking …

The Bradfo Show: Talking Bruins roster moves with DJ Bean, Turtleboy

Rob Bradford is joined by WEEI.com Bruins beat writer DJ Bean, as well as Boston sports fan/blogger Turtleboy to talk all things Bruins free agency. With the B's recent moves, the conversation turns to where the Bruins might next turn and what kind of dent losing Jarome Iginla and Shawn Thornton might make.

DJ Bean breaks down the first hours of NHL Free Agency 7-1-14

DJ discusses Shawn Thornton's new deal, and the on going negotiations with Jerome Iginla

DJ Bean, WEEI.com. The Bruins are not traded Marchand 6-13-14

DJ Bean joins the program to dismiss the recent rumors that the Bruins are in discussions to trade Brad Marchand to the Sharks for Patrick Marleau

Gordon Edes: "95% chance …

Gordon Edes: "95% chance Lester gets traded" 7-30-14

ESPN Boston's Gordon Edes gave us the latest on the Lester trade talks.

Headlines, Headlines, Headlines: Hillary Clinton wants to change the Redskins mascot 7-30-14

The top stories of the day as recounted by John Dennis.

Jon Lester scratched 7-30-14

Joh, Gerry and Buck opened the show by discussing the latest rumors surrounding Jon Lester.

Three For All: Christian'…

Three For All: Christian's girlfriend calls him out, 7-29-14

Christian tells a story about taking his girlfriend to see "Jersey Boys" in NYC, but he leaves out some crucial details. Luckily, she was listening and called the show to clarify exactly what kind of shenanigans he was trying to pull.

The NFL is taking a look at "high-stakes" Fantasy Football, 7-29-14

MFB discuss a Peter King article that suggests many NFL coaches and assistant coaches have felt increasing pressure over big-money fantasy football players. Christian also weighs in specifically on how his knowledge of game-plans resulted directly in him winning his first season as a fantasy football player.

Red Sox routed by Blue Jays as trade rumors swirl, 7-29-14

The Sox lost 14-1 as Clay Buchholz and Felix Doubront both had awful performances. On the heels of the loss, rumors began to fly regarding Jon Lester and John Lackey possibly being traded.

Have we seen the last of …

Have we seen the last of Jon Lester in a Red Sox uniform?

The tweet is a little ominous sounding. Dale, Buck and Greg Dickerson discuss what very well could be the end of the Jon Lester era with the Boston Red Sox.

Dale and Holley's Four at Four - Championship Hangover Edition - 7-29-14

We tackle four topics all sparked by the Red Sox worst to first to worst run in 2012-2014.

Jon Lester is on the table, will he end up in LA? 7-28-14

We talk about the latest news surrounding Jon Lester and the Red Sox. Could he be dealt to the Dodgers?

Jon Lester's Contract Sit…

Jon Lester's Contract Situation and the Future

Mut and Villani are talking about whether the Red Sox will give Jon Lester the type of contract he is looking for, or whether they might be shopping him with rumors of the Red Sox scouting Cole Hamels.

The All Star Game and the Worst Ideas in Sports

Mut and Villani are talking about the MLB All Star Game, Adam Wainwright and Derek Jeter, and what are some of the worst ideas in sports.

We're all yelling about LeBron James

Producer's Podcast-Is Leb…

Producer's Podcast-Is Lebron a Genius? 7-29-14

Sam and Zach discuss changing the format of the Podcast, the Chris Archer-David Ortiz debacle, and LeBron James being a super genius

Minor Details Ep. 94.2 with Jim Callis of MLB.com: Are Red Sox prospects overvalued?

Particularly in a year where the Red Sox have struggled while trying to integrate numerous young players into regular big league roles, accusations that Red Sox prospects are overrated -- whether by the team or writers -- have been widespread. Jim Callis of MLB.com joins the show to take stock of the matter, and to discuss the team-building impact of overrating and underrating prospects.

Minor Details Ep. 94.1: Are prospects overvalued? Andrew Miller on being traded for Miguel Cabrera

With the trade deadline looming, the next few days will be defined by how teams value prospects -- and their potential long-term contributions -- against big leaguers with established track records who can address immediate needs. Are prospects being valued accurately? Red Sox left-hander Andrew Miller -- once one of the two key chips that sent Miguel Cabrera from the Marlins to the Tigers -- assesses the matter.

Rob Bradford on the lates…

Rob Bradford on the latest with the Sox at the deadline 7-28-14

Rob gave the latest on Jon Lester trade talks and the flap between Ortiz and the Rays.

More from this show

Minor Details Ep. 94.2 wi…

Minor Details Ep. 94.2 with Jim Callis of MLB.com: Are Red Sox prospects overvalued?

Particularly in a year where the Red Sox have struggled while trying to integrate numerous young players into regular big league roles, accusations that Red Sox prospects are overrated -- whether by the team or writers -- have been widespread. Jim Callis of MLB.com joins the show to take stock of the matter, and to discuss the team-building impact of overrating and underrating prospects.

More from this show

Jon Lester is on the tabl…

Jon Lester is on the table, will he end up in LA? 7-28-14

We talk about the latest news surrounding Jon Lester and the Red Sox. Could he be dealt to the Dodgers?

More from this show

David Ortiz offends the R…

David Ortiz offends the Rays again 7-28-14

John, Meter and Buck opened the show by discussing the latest flap between the Red Sox and the Rays.

More from this show

Gordon Edes: "95% chance …

Gordon Edes: "95% chance Lester gets traded" 7-30-14

ESPN Boston's Gordon Edes gave us the latest on the Lester trade talks.

More from this show

Weei Writers